When restoring or maintaining a Porsche 356 Roadster, sourcing the right parts is critical. Two heavy hitters in the Porsche parts world are Pelican Parts and Soddard. Both offer extensive catalogs for the 356, but they have distinct strengths. This article compares them on parts quality, availability, pricing, and customer support so you can make an informed decision.
Background on Pelican Parts and Soddard
Pelican Parts started in 1995 as a small parts supplier and grew into one of the largest independent Porsche parts retailers. They carry OEM, aftermarket, and performance parts for all Porsche models, including the 356. Their website is user-friendly with technical articles and part diagrams.
Soddard is a specialized restoration parts supplier focused exclusively on the Porsche 356 and early 911 models. They are known for high-quality reproduction parts and deep expertise in 356 restoration. They operate a dedicated workshop and offer custom fabrication services.
Quality of Parts
Pelican Parts
Pelican offers a mix of OEM and aftermarket parts. For the 356 Roadster, you’ll find parts sourced from reputable manufacturers like Porsche Classic, Original Fit, and other suppliers. Their aftermarket components often meet or exceed OEM specs, but some generic parts may have fitment variations. Pelican does quality checks but relies primarily on brand reputation.
Soddard
Soddard focuses on restoration-grade parts, often replicating original designs with modern materials. Their sheet metal, rubber seals, and interior components are highly regarded. Many owners prefer Soddard for body panels and trim because of precise reproduction. Soddard also manufactures some parts in-house, ensuring consistency.
If OEM authenticity matters most, Soddard edges ahead. For everyday mechanical parts where aftermarket is fine, Pelican is solid.
Availability and Inventory
Pelican Parts has a massive warehouse and frequently stocks 356 Roadster parts. Their online system shows real-time inventory. However, some specialty parts may be backordered. Pelican also offers rapid shipping options.
Soddard has a smaller inventory but specializes in rare and hard-to-find parts. They often stock items that Pelican doesn’t, such as specific trim clips, emblems, or glass. But their stock can turn over quickly. For common maintenance items, Pelican is more likely to have them in stock.
Pricing
Pelican Parts is known for competitive pricing on many items. They run sales and discounts, and loyalty programs help reduce costs. However, prices for authentic Porsche Classic parts can be high.
Soddard’s prices are generally higher, reflecting the restoration-grade quality and rarity. You pay a premium for accuracy and exclusivity. But when you factor in the cost of returns or rework due to poor fit, Soddard can be more economical.
Customer Support and Expertise
Pelican has a knowledgeable phone support team and a dedicated tech forum. Their website includes extensive DIY guides. But because they handle many models, support reps may not have deep 356-specific knowledge.
Soddard’s staff are passionate 356 restorers themselves. They offer restoration consulting, custom orders, and can answer detailed questions about your Roadster. This personalized service is invaluable for a complex restoration.
Shipping and Returns
Pelican has standard 30-day returns and free shipping over a certain amount. They use major carriers and ship internationally.
Soddard’s return policy is more restrictive due to the nature of their parts. They accept returns for defects but may charge restocking fees. Shipping costs are higher because they are a smaller shop.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Pelican Parts if:
- You need routine maintenance parts (filters, belts, gaskets).
- You want lower prices and frequent deals.
- You prefer an easy online shopping experience with live inventory.
- You are comfortable with mid-range aftermarket parts.
Choose Soddard if:
- You are doing a concours-level restoration.
- You need exact reproduction body panels or interior pieces.
- You require expert advice on rare parts.
- You are willing to pay more for authenticity.
Final Recommendation
For your Porsche 356 Roadster, start with Pelican Parts for general mechanical and electrical components. Use Soddard for sheet metal, trim, and anything that needs to be period-correct. A combination of both suppliers gives you the best balance of cost, availability, and quality. If in doubt, consult Soddard’s specialists before ordering critical parts. A successful restoration comes from using the right part for the right purpose.